Unsatisfactory
0-11
No
introduction
or no
conclusion,
or either is
ineffective,
poorly
organized, or
undeveloped.
0-11
References
process, but
does not
explore it
with any
depth.
0-11
Defines some
outcomes but
does not
define all. It
is unclear
how the
examples tie
to the
outcomes.
There are not
examples for
each
outcome.
0-11
Generalizes
on changes
which were
made in
revision, but
doesn’t
analyze
original
paper nor
why the
changes
were made.
0-11
Reflection
essay is not
formatted as a
letter.
Consistent
lack of
coherent
organization of
ideas within
paragraphs and
from one
paragraph to
the
next; points of
paragraphs are
unclear.
Frequent
syntax,
grammar, or
misspelling
errors that
distract the
reader.
0-11
Revisions
don’t affect
how well the
paper meets
the prompt, or
are not
appropriate to
the
assignment.
0-11
Makes local
revision or
global
revisions, but
not both.
0-11
All changes
are based on
the instructor’s
comments.
0-12
Changes are
not
consistently
noted.